top of page

Understanding the Benefits and Downsides of Discount Types for Shopify Ecommerce Stores

  • Writer: Ben Staveley
    Ben Staveley
  • Sep 21
  • 3 min read

In the bustling landscape of ecommerce, offering discounts is a widely used tactic to attract customers and drive sales. However, not all discount types provide the same benefits. This blog post will explore the advantages and disadvantages of three popular discount types: fixed value off, percentage off, and free shipping. By understanding these distinctions, Shopify store owners can make informed choices that align with their business strategies.


Fixed Value Off Discounts


Fixed value off discounts provide customers with a specific amount deducted from their total purchase. For example, imagine a store that offers $10 off orders that exceed $50.


Benefits


The simplicity of fixed value off discounts is one of their major advantages. Customers know exactly what they will save, which encourages them to complete their purchase. This type of discount works particularly well for high-ticket items. If a customer purchases an item priced at $200, a discount of $10 feels substantial and can motivate them to buy.


Moreover, fixed value discounts can boost the average order value. By requiring a minimum purchase of $50, businesses can encourage customers to add extra items to their baskets. In fact, a study found that retailers using minimum purchase thresholds experienced a 20% increase in average order values.


Downsides


However, fixed value off discounts can lead to lower profit margins if the discount is set too high. If customers start making purchases solely to benefit from the discount, the long-term viability of this strategy can be jeopardized.


Another issue is that not all shoppers may find fixed dollar amounts appealing. Customers buying lower-priced items, like a $15 product, may prefer a percentage discount, as $10 off may not seem as attractive.


Close-up view of a shopping cart filled with various products
A shopping cart filled with products ready for checkout

Percentage Off Discounts


Percentage off discounts offer a specific percentage reduction on the total purchase price. For instance, a store might advertise a 20% off sale on items during a clearance event.


Benefits


Percentage off discounts resonate strongly with customers, particularly for larger purchases. A discount of 20% on a $100 item saves the customer $20, making it feel like a great deal. This type of discount also caters to a diverse range of shoppers, as it applies to any order size.


Additionally, these discounts can effectively clear out inventory. According to recent statistics, 60% of consumers feel a sense of urgency when they see a percentage off sale, spurring faster purchasing decisions.


Downsides


On the downside, percentage off discounts can foster consumer habits where people wait for sales, leading to lower sales during regular pricing periods. This can create a cycle, where customers only buy when discounts are available, adversely affecting revenue.


Confusion can also arise with percentage discounts. Some customers may struggle to calculate the final purchase price, increasing the likelihood of cart abandonment. A survey showed that 30% of shoppers left their carts due to unclear pricing structures.


Eye-level view of a colorful display of various clothing items
A colorful display of clothing items in a retail setting

Free Shipping Discounts


Free shipping discounts remove shipping costs for customers, which can significantly influence purchasing decisions. A study found that around 53% of shoppers abandon their carts due to high shipping fees.


Benefits


The primary advantage of free shipping is its ability to reduce cart abandonment rates. When customers know they won’t face additional shipping fees, they are more likely to complete their purchases. Retailers with free shipping see a 30% increase in conversion rates.


Free shipping also enhances the shopping experience. It streamlines the checkout process and gives customers a sense of getting a better overall deal, even if product prices remain the same.


Downsides


Nonetheless, offering free shipping can impact profit margins, especially for smaller ecommerce businesses. If not carefully managed, shipping costs can erode profits.


Furthermore, free shipping may not be sustainable without minimum purchase requirements. Frequently offering it without conditions could lead to financial strain. Setting a minimum order value can mitigate this issue, but it may deter some customers from making smaller purchases.


Final Thoughts


In summary, each discount type—fixed value off, percentage off, and free shipping—has unique benefits and drawbacks. Understanding these can empower Shopify store owners to tailor their discount strategies effectively.


When deciding which discount type to implement, consider your target audience and the specific goals of your ecommerce store. Testing various discount strategies can reveal what resonates most with your customers.


By carefully evaluating the pros and cons of each discount type, Shopify store owners can make informed choices that enhance customer satisfaction, increase sales, and build long-term loyalty in the competitive ecommerce landscape.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page